Question:
The Elves of Fyn, are they real and is there any solid proof?
BlackRose
2012-06-09 13:36:07 UTC
I'm curious about this. I have seen many people opposed to this whole subject so I ask that only those who are -knowledgeable- in this area to please answer this question.
I know that there is a group of elves called The Elves Of Fyn and that they are roughly located in Norway, Denmark, Ireland, or Scotland. Is there any circumstantial evidence that they exist? Any thing that is solid at all? Did their people really go to faerie realm because mankind became so greedy and hateful to them?
Any information to this subject will be much appreciated.
Of course I am completely sane as I write this and am not drunk nor high just incase some of you might ask.
Three answers:
anonymous
2012-06-09 15:00:10 UTC
You mean the island of Fyn in Denmark? You know, I checked online, and the only hit that claimed to have any knowledge of the "elves" was "realfairies.com", which I hardly think counts as a source properly based on empirical results.



I will try to be neutral, as although I find the whole idea ridiculous, I have had some mythologism as a part of my History classes at university, so I have spme eperience with tales of the supernatural and people who believes in it.



Now, the following is merely my own memory from lectures on Celtic and Norse mythology, so I reserve the possibility for minor mistakes.



What the "Elves of Fyn" are claimed to be has the Celtic version of elves in nature, a version that for example manifests itself in the Leprechauns (although the site claims them to be something else, which I will come to soon) of Ireland. However, their appearance appear to be based on the Norse elf version, made famous through Tolkien. The Norse human-sized elf does in Norse mythology live in another world, Álfheimr. However, this place is in no way similar to the human realm, Midgard, but rather covered in forest. The light elves, all blonde, are "fairer than the sun to look at". The dark elves are all black-haired and live undergound in another world. However, elves have not existed in Scandinavian mythology for more than a millennia. The only creature remotely similar to elves are the "nisser", small gnome-like creatures looking like Santa that kills livestock unless you sacrifice porridge to them on Christmas eve, a remnant of the Norse winter sacrifice to the gods, taking place the 22nd. If the elves were real, the myths would have remained, right?



Anyway, there is no empirical or scientifical evidence for the existence of elves whatsoever. Several times in history people have claimed to, as with all kinds of mythological creatures, prove their existence. However, it has all been exposed as fraud over time, people trying to become rich or famous. I can with 100% certainty tell you that elves do not exist, and certainly not living in a world corresponding to ours. And even in Norse mythology it was not possible to cross between the elven world and our world. Only the gods could pass in and out of their world, or lead elves out, as the lack of a Bifrost connection necessitated travelling along the invisible roots of Yggdrasil, the locations of which are known only by the gods.
?
2012-06-09 20:47:37 UTC
There are no evidence for the existence of Elves, people have been searching for elves (and other mythical creatures) for hundreds of years... And guess what has been found...





Thats right, NOTHING!

Reports of elves and other stuff like them usually come from people who have a record of mental illness or in newer cases, substance abusers.

Mythical creatures are, as their name indicate, mythical.





Oh, and my logic dictates that the "Elves of Fyn" (In the unlikely case that they exist) should be located on... Oh I dont know, the island "Fyn" maybe? Just a thought...
?
2012-06-10 04:17:33 UTC
@Richyboy. I, most certainly am no god, at least by human understanding, but I know these paths that you speak of. In fact, sometimes I freelance as a guide on them. Oh, and if you go back in my family tree, you find connections to the royalty of Scotland, Ireland, and England.



Op, I do not know whether the specific group of elves you are referring to exists, but there are decedents of elves from families whom lived in that region.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...